When designing and planning this house Adam and I knew we wanted a lot of rustic features inside our home. Metal ceilings, antique beams, shiplap siding, brick flooring, rock walls, and rustic wood ceilings and floors were all things we wanted to incorporate in one way or another. We particularity wanted an entire rock wall on one of the walls in the main living space. After finalizing our blueprints we were like “We’re going to put the rock wall HERE. Okay, no… here? Well, that won’t work…how about here?” In the end, none of the walls in the main space were going to work either for structural reasons or monetary reasons, so instead we decided to just put rock on the fireplace (and plank the wall behind it.) Here is what the fireplace looked like right after the drywall was installed…
Then one day Adam and I swung by the house to check on progress, and this was happening…
I think I audibly squealed when I saw it, which isn’t normally a thing I do…but if this isn’t squeal-worthy then I don’t know what it. It’s just so pretty. Also, I was a little in awe of the guy up at the top. I mean….he’s up there, and he has to haul heavy rocks and mortar up there with him. No thank you.
The next day I came back to check the finished product, which was pretty much amazing…except for one tiiiiny little detail.
The mantel was really high. It’s hard to tell from the picture because there is nothing to compare it too (I would have taken one with me in it but I was there alone), but it was about 2 feet over my head. Actually, see that doorway on the right? That is an 8 foot doorway, and the mantel is almost as tall as it is. After going back and forth about what to do Adam and I decided to ask the rock crew to lower the mantel the next time they were there.
Much better, right?
The hearth is a big limestone slab (well, two actually), and we had it made at chair height so it can serve as extra seating. So far so good, it’s currently the only seating in the house and gets used nonstop (for sitting, eating, putting all our junk, coloring while your parents work, etc.)
Here is the view from the dining room…
That’s not all we ended up putting rock on though, as a somewhat last-minute decision we decided to go ahead and have them do the main wall in the master bedroom. It was pretty much the perfect place for it, plus it would satisfy that rock wall craving we had going on.
Here is something I didn’t know before building a house… when you when you see a home with a masonry, the rock isn’t actually touching the house (usually…I’m sure there’s plenty of exceptions).
The rock is it’s own, self-supporting wall. I had just assumed it was mortared to the wall (like I did on the wall in my guest room), but I was wrong. It is attached to the wall every so often with a little metal brace, but other than that it’s just standing there on it’s own (they did it the same way on the outside). I’m sure there is a great reason why they do it like that, but I have no idea what it is.
Anyway, here is the finished product. It’s amazing and I can’t believe it’s in my house.
I love the thick “German Smear” mortar, it’s much thicker than on the outside of the house and I like it much better. To get it that way Adam and I had to stop worrying about being “those people” and stand over their shoulders saying “more, more, more..” until the mortar was just how we wanted it. Sometimes you just gotta.
We still have a few finishing touches to put on the wall, like figuring out windowsills and what to do about the drywall that shows around the windows.
I’ll probably just paint the drywall to match the mortar so that you don’t notice it, and the windows sills will most likely just be white wood. We thought limestone slab sills would be cool (like on the fireplace hearth), but they would be too thick add the windows wouldn’t function. So wood it is.
So, price….I know y’all are probably wondering how much dough we sank into this because it looks expensive. Truth be told it was much more affordable that we thought it would be, each one (the fireplace and bedroom wall) cost a little over a thousand each. Considering the Airstone wall I did a year or so ago was about $500 and half the size (and included about a month of my labor while pregnant), this was a steal. And while I still really like that wall, the two just don’t compare.
Am I right or am I right?
Vicky says
June 6, 2016 at 11:00 amlove it!!!
Sarah says
June 6, 2016 at 11:12 am(Ex-architect-geek hat again…)
Your bedroom wall material was light enough to be suspended by its adhesive and the adhesive’s substrate (the drywall). The stone you’re using now is too heavy to not be a self-supporting veneer – it would overpower the adhesive, or fracture itself near the adhesive plane, or fracture the drywall. The metal masonry clips you saw are used to keep the veneer layer (the technical term is ‘wythe’) attached to the real structure, the studs + sheathing, so when the entire structure shifts slightly and repeatedly under a wind load or thermal expansion, the whole thing doesn’t come teetering down with a crash. Comparing ‘modulus of rupture’ properties of the materials: Indiana limestone is only expected to be 1100psi in one spec I found, 1/2″ drywall looks like 750psi, compare those to 9400psi in ponderosa pine. So if you tried to adhere a sizeable piece of limestone to 1/2″ drywall, I’d expect the weight of the limestone, upon any horizontal movement of the wall, to tear the drywall apart.
Ashley says
June 6, 2016 at 12:31 pmThank you for that explanation! I knew the drywall wasn’t strong enough to support the weight of the stone, I just wasn’t sure why there was such a large gap (why it’s not touching the drywall, but still self supporting). I figured moisture.
Sarah says
June 7, 2016 at 12:24 pmMoisture is always a great guess, though on the conditioned space side of drywall you really shouldn’t have any… ;) However, they are doing the veneer exactly as they would for an exterior veneer, in which case moisture IS the answer…you want to be sure that there’s a clear gap between the veneer (which is somewhat porous to water) and the vapor barrior on the sheathing. So that what seeps through will run down the inside face of the wythe without sliding across any bridging detritus (as in your picture, but you’re indoors, so ok) but those clips to touch the sheathing.
Jamie says
June 6, 2016 at 12:33 pmThis is so awesome! I’m so excited for you that you get to make every single detail of this house what you want! I love seeing the progress! :)
Anna says
June 6, 2016 at 1:35 pmwow!!! The master bedroom wall looks amazing! I am not a stone girl myself but I really click with your style so I had to check it out. I have to say I think I’ve come around! It’s so light and airy!
Bethany says
June 6, 2016 at 3:18 pmThis is completely stunning. Perfect in every way! We’re currently doing a budget remodel on our house, which restricts some of our choices. But if we were to build a home from the ground up, I would choose this. Thanks for sharing your journey!
Linda - Make Do and DIY says
June 6, 2016 at 4:34 pmLove the stone in the bedroom! So warm looking. And I can’t wait to see a pic of you beside the fireplace, cos at the moment it’s making me think the whole place is smaller than it obviously really is. Theoretically I can see how big it is compared to the doorway, but my brain just won’t accept it! lol
Ashley says
June 6, 2016 at 9:27 pmWe are having a work day out there on Saturday, I will have someone take a picture then and post it right here in the comments for you!
Ashley says
June 13, 2016 at 11:26 amHere you go!
Jan Elizabeth says
June 6, 2016 at 10:03 pmThat fireplace is totally squeal-worthy! And you’re right, there’s just no comparison between the airstone and the real limestone. It’s totally gorgeous!!
liz says
June 7, 2016 at 6:59 amOkay, that stone is so over the top AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL!!!!!! I am a stone person myself, and I am loving all of your design choices – good move on putting it in the bedroom, it totally makes that wall, especially with the old wood toppers above the windows – stone & wood, a perfect combination.
Chris says
June 7, 2016 at 9:27 amLove that beautiful stone wall in the Master Bedroom. Reminds me of the log cabin my grandmother lived in back in Maryland. Amazing how something so hard and earthy can give such a warm, cozy feel. Your dream house is coming along beautifully!
Brandi in NB says
June 7, 2016 at 11:25 amHoly hello! That looks absolutely stunning. Perfect rock and smear choice. And the vault in the master….perfection! We are getting ready to start building in SB, too. I may be needing some of your suppliers’/contractors’ names. I’ll just tell them “make it just like Ashley’s”.
On a side note, what kind of window treatments will you do with that wood beam header over the window? Assuming you won’t want to cover it with curtains, etc.
Ashley says
June 9, 2016 at 8:22 amDo you already have a builder? Have we already talked about this via e-mail?
For the windows I was thinking about doing a roman shade. I think that’s actually the only solution since I don’t want to cover the headers or drill holes in the rock.
Beth says
June 7, 2016 at 1:25 pmThis looks fantastic! You were right about the mantel. Much better where it is now!
Stephanie says
June 7, 2016 at 2:37 pmI am in love with your fireplace and bedroom wall!! I love any type of European home inspiration. :)
Lindsay says
June 9, 2016 at 3:46 pmSo. When you’re finished building this house, I’m going to need you guys to come to Utah and build one for me. Okay? I’ll wait until after your baby is born…
Morgan says
June 28, 2016 at 1:05 pmI absolutely love this! This house is so unique, and it looks great! Congratulations on making so much progress! Keep it up!
Tom says
October 24, 2016 at 9:43 amVery good post was amazing and very explanatory congratulations on the site
Jackie says
March 3, 2018 at 4:09 pmHello,
I like the color, texture and size of rock on the fireplace, can you tell me the name and where you purchased it?
Beautiful home~
Ashley Schill says
March 16, 2018 at 10:34 amI love your bedroom wall! We are doing a remodel on a 1960’s California ranch home and I want to do an accent wall of limestone with a German schmear! Funny you mentioned air stone because we did a different project with it and it was good but by no means compares to the real thing. Can you tell me the name of it and where you got it? Thanks!
Ashley says
March 19, 2018 at 6:50 amYes, airstone was good but the real thing is so much better! The limestone we used is just cream limestone in a medium chop. I don’t know where it’s from (the builder ordered it), but here in south central Texas it is the easiest to find, most generic stone you can buy.
Matthew Turner says
September 27, 2018 at 2:53 pmThe rock fireplace and walls are gorgeous! Wherever did you find that stone? Can you share the resource? Thanks,
Matthew
Ashley says
October 2, 2018 at 8:38 pmIt is just cream limestone, around here it is the most common and least expensive option.
brett eskelson says
December 4, 2018 at 2:35 pmHi there,
I love this rock! Do you remember where you got it from?
https://www.domesticimperfection.com/interior-limestone/
Ashley says
December 5, 2018 at 8:07 amYes! It’s a cream limestone chop from Cobra Stone.
Chris Permenter says
December 10, 2018 at 10:51 amWow! I’m so jealous. We too are in renovation. We are about to build our fireplace. Where did you buy your limestone rock and limestone slab? I loved seeing your fireplace. This is pretty much the direction we are hoping to go. How big is your actual fireplace insert? What are your fireplace dimensions? Sorry for so many questions….I think I’m desperate. I have been thinking about our fireplace for over a year. Also — your bedroom is soooooo lovely!!!
Joanne R says
March 22, 2019 at 6:37 pmCan you tell me what the stone is ~ manufacture or color etc. it’s beautiful !
Ashley says
March 24, 2019 at 7:13 pmThank you! It is cream limestone (3in 6in 9in), we got ours from Cobra Stone.
Rosemarie says
January 13, 2020 at 11:46 amI love your wall. I have a cultered stone floor to ceiling fireplace that is a cream colour with grey mortar. It needs help! Do you have any advice in painting/German Schmearing it?
Judi says
February 4, 2020 at 2:16 pmPlease send the name of the interior limestone product and where to get it. Name and brand of morter. Absolutely stunning!
Carmela says
February 25, 2020 at 12:39 pmHi Ashley,
What an amazingly beautiful job you did with your new home interior and exterior! It truly represents an Old World European home! It’s stunning!! Great architectural design choices!I’m very impressed!! I happen to Love Europian and French Prvencial Design. I’m in awe of your home.
I am working on remodeling the exterior of my home and some interior spaces of my traditional center hall colonial. I would like to incorporate some Limestone veneers on the exterior as currently the facade is brick and sides and back of home is siding. In addition some interior lime stone walls, possibly entrance, kitchen nook and or family room.
I live in NJ and was wondering how much per sq ft did you pay for the gorgeous cream Limestone veneers? How much was the cost for the front of the home including install? And what was the cost for stone and install for fireplace stone and bedroom wall? Can you please include labor costs and stone prices for each project? Do you know of any stone yards in NJ that would carry similar Limestone at a low price end. Everything is sooo expensive here in NJ.
I would greatly appreciate your help!
Thankyou,
Carmela