Guest Room Paper Flooring (and why I’m disappointed with it)

This summer I started redoing my guest room, and the first step was new flooring. I wanted to do paper bag floors, mostly because they’re cheap and beautiful, but also because I wanted the flooring to match in my boy’s room and the guest room (they’re right next to each other).

CLICK HERE TO READ MY ORIGINAL POST ABOUT INSTALLING PAPER BAG FLOORS

(If you aren’t familiar with paper bag flooring process then please read the original tutorial first. Links to the follow-up posts can be found at the bottom of that post.)

So, let’s start at the beginning.

I wanted this floor to match my boys floor exactly, so I used the same brown paper, same stain, and same technique. The only thing I changed was the sealer I put on top.

First, we ripped out the old carpet, filled the holes, and ripped and wrinkled the paper, cleaned the floor…all the prep work.

removing-carpet

Then I started glueing. I used a 50/50 mix of Elmers glue and water and worked with my bare hands, dunking the paper in the mixture and smoothing it out on the floor.

installing a paper bag floor

After I finished and everything dried for a day, I stained. I used oil based Minwax stain in Provincial, mopping it on with a deck pad.

staining a paper floor

I let that dry for a day or so, then went ahead and sealed it. Here is where it gets interesting.

When I did my paper bag experiments this summer I had a clear winner when it came to sealers…Bona Traffic, hands down. It was bulletproof on my test board and I was excited to get it on my floor. I sealed the boy’s room with water based poly for floors a couple of years ago, and although it was holding up okay it definitely wasn’t doing great (you can read that update post HERE). I planned to reseal the boy’s room with the Bona Traffic as well.

Bona Traffic

The Bona traffic is a two-part sealer, it has the sealer and a bottle of hardener you mix in. When I was ready to get started sealing I went ahead and poured the entire bottle of hardener into the sealer and got to work. After I finished the first coat I started reading the back of the container while waiting for it to dry. Right there, on the back, in tiny letters it clearly said “The finish/hardener mixture must be used within 4 hours after it is mixed. Product properties are diminished after 4 hours.” OH SNAP (not the actual phrase that came to mind at that moment, but we’ll use it here). I had read that part before while doing experiments…how did I forget? There is no way I could use that whole bottle in four hours…that didn’t leave it nearly enough drying time between coats.

Luckily it was a Saturday morning when this happened and Adam was home. I told him my predicament and explained that we had to empty out the boy’s room RIGHT NOW so I could prep and seal it before my expensive sealer was rendered useless. He sighed, shook his head, mumbled something about “only you..”, and we quickly destroyed our house.

renovation disorganization

The first coat of Traffic sealer I applied to the guest room floor actually dried really quickly (in like 30 minutes) so I added another coat while prepping the boys floor.

Do you remember how I had that corner in the boy’s room where the sealer was flaking up? I never did figure out what was causing it. Anyway, scraped it up as best I could (and tried to pull it up with tape – fail) before adding more sealer on top.

flaking sealer

My hope was that when I added the new sealer would kinda melt into the old and you wouldn’t be able to tell that was a problem area (spoiler – that didn’t happen).

Anyway, I went back and forth sealing both rooms in 30 minute intervals. The boy’s room received two coats (over the previous twelve of the original sealer) and the guest room received four.

Here is that problem area when the new sealer dried…it doesn’t look great.

boys problem corner

Luckily the bed goes in that corner and we’ll never see it. The rest of the room looked amazing…

brown paper floor - final

And here’s what the guest room floor looked like…

paper sack floor

paper floor closeup

paper flooring

And both of them side by side…

paper flooring done a year and a half apart

I let the rooms cure for nearly a week before putting all the furniture back in, which I felt was more than enough time.

Since then (this was about six months ago) is when I have become pretty frustrated with the floors. The Bona Traffic is not holding up like I had hoped. It doesn’t scratch and flake up like the previous sealer, but instead it blisters. blistering sealer

When I tested this sealer it was bulletproof, I’m not even exaggerating. I dug at it with a fork and you could barely tell. I was sure I would be able to abuse my floors with no consequences…but thats not the case at all. I think the difference is that for my experiments I waited about 24 hours between coats of sealer, and with this I obviously rushed it and added four coats in about three hours. It’s likely that it never cured properly. Or maybe putting this on a concrete floor vs. a wood floor is what makes the difference (though I doubt it). I don’t really know, all I know is that I have delicate floors and they frustrate me. I still think the Bona is a great sealer, and if your going to use it just DONT RUSH.

Both floors still look great if you stand back a bit, and if the sealer blisters up I can just cut it out and add more sealer. It’s not the end of the world, I’m just done messing with them. I wish we could have extended the wood flooring into the bedrooms when we did our living room and hallway a few years ago, but we simply couldn’t afford to at the time. I’m not going to replace the paper flooring when we sell no mater how it looks, we’ll just offer a carpeting allowance for any buyers that side-eye the paper bag flooring.

I know this paper bag floor thing can be done and be tough (I’ve had people e-mail me and say they’ve had it in their house for ten or twenty years and it looks great). I haven’t mastered it yet though….and honestly, I never will. I won’t ever paper a floor again.

Anyway, after all the paper bag experiments this summer I thought an update was needed. I wish it was a better one!

Like it? Share it!Pin on Pinterest290Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on StumbleUpon52Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0


Comments

  1. I think they look great. I would guess the moisture in the concrete would impact the sealant too.

    • First, let me say how much I enjoy your posts. So inspiring. Second, we used the same stuff on our hardwood and it too blistered. The manufacturer insisted it was because the surface we put it on (stained) was not completely dry. We had waited 14 days after staining, even longer than the recommended time. So we started all over. The second time around, it worked much better and seems to be ok. This stuff is finicky. Maybe a light sanding would help?? Good luck!

      • I agree with the sanding! I bet if you did a light sanding over the entire flooring and vacuumed really good between each layer of epoxy your results may have been different. Maybe if not I between each layer of epoxy, just before the final coat of epoxy.

  2. Hi! Sorry your floors didn’t turn out as you would have liked! I still think they look pretty good. I hope you are doing well!
    Lauren @ Mom Home Guide recently posted..Pom Pom Holiday WreathMy Profile

  3. Jan Elizabeth says:

    Aww, sorry to hear that. After all your tons and tons of hard work. :(

  4. Ellie a.k.a :) says:

    They look great Ashley, new and shiny! Where are you getting all this energy from?? You’re making me tired just reading about it and I have no excuse…other than getting older, lol! Thanks for experimenting for us.

  5. Hmm… Blistering does sound a little like something is happening under the paper. It sounds like you have a an issue with the base. They really look very cool and I hope you don’t have any more issues with them!
    Susan recently posted..Master Bathroom Updates (Part 2)My Profile

  6. Sorry to see the blistering that is happening. You put a lot of time and energy into the floors but I think they still look pretty good. Mot sure how they look IRL but on my screen they remind me of wood floors.

  7. As one who has lived on concrete floors for a number of years, and had many fails of remodeling floors, concrete DOES make a difference. It not only absorbs the heat and cold of the ground, but it absorbs moisture as well. We learned to lay down a moisture barrier between the concrete and whatever we were putting over it. End of problems.

    It does add expense, as we’re not talking ordinary wood, but a special type of wood (from hardware store). But it was worth it in the end, as the flooring finally stopped buckling and breaking and doing other not so fun things over a short period of time.

    • Yup, that concrete is porous, and moisture travels through it, albeit slowly. (Former architect here.) You may not have a vapor barrier (like 6 mil Visqueen) under your concrete slab. (Even if you did, if the house is fairly new, the concrete takes a long time to cure – houses off-gas all sorts of chemicals including water for a surprisingly long time.)
      Good on you for a great experiment, and an interesting technique. The only way we know anything at all about building is by failing – at real scale and expense. (For a fun read, try “How Buildings Fail”.)

  8. The floors look very nice from the pictures. You are a very energenic and talented woman!

  9. I have never done this technique, but I did notice you used an oil based stain with a water based finish. You should use compatible products–oil stain with oil based fiinish, water based stain with water based finish. The only exception–an oil based finish can go over a water based stain. I have used the latter sucessfully.

    • If you read her blog on the sealers, you will see why she chose a oil based stain with a water based finish.

    • @ Christine – An oil based stain with a water based poly sealer is very common in wood floor installations and works perfectly. However, an oil based poly can never be applied over a water based stain.

  10. Marina Garcia says:

    It’s the drying time! I used it on the floors and waited, as per instructions, between curing the coats. It’s been a year and the floors look fab. Then, I used it on a wooden table. Rushed between the coats (it’s a table, not the floors, right?) Wrong. it bubbled up. I called the customer service, the old fashion way, to complain and rather quickly was explained that there is a reason why instructions say to wait ;-) Lesson learned the hard way…

  11. I did this method on our classroom floor about a year ago. I actually followed the first paperboy tutorial to a T, but alas… paper is not meant for floors. Read my story and check out our pictures a year after install.
    http://onblissstreet.blogspot.com
    Erica recently posted..Hop in my Delorean and let’s go back in time…. Paper bag flooring.My Profile

  12. Thanks Ashley for sharing the article. I think the idea of paper flooring is not bad and it makes the floor looks beautiful and also cost effective.

  13. Love your floors and sorry they aren’t working out. I know how frustrating that is. As someone who grew up in a family with a floor care business, I’d definitely say the blisters are caused from moisture. I’ve seen many sealers do this over the years due to moisture and even from cleaning a floor with water. Concrete sucks up moisture from the air and the soil underneath continuously. Also as someone pointed out, never mix oil and latex as that can also cause cracking, blistering, peeling effects and problems.

  14. Did your Minwax stain have a sealant in it? If so, it will probably react with any other sealant that you put on top of it….

  15. So sorry your sealer gave you issues. I did paper bag floors to my play room and other than some of the nails from the subfloor poking up a little they turned out great. I did go through and re-seal again but 2 years later they still look great.
    Lesley recently posted..The Great Dust BowlMy Profile

  16. I know you said you’ll never do paper flooring again but, if you could go back in time, would you do this project again? Would you use the Bona Traffic, given your problems, or one of the other sealers? Thanks!

  17. When I do my paper floors I use the poly to “glue” the paper down and let it dry really well. Then I put 3-4 coats of poly over that. I don’t have any of the White looking problem you had. I think it has to do with the glue becoming wet and turning back white. AND using the poly as the glue gives extra hardness to the finish… I just dip my paper pieces in a container of poly instead of glue and proceed…. I hope this helps. And when I get a scratch I just add another coat of poly to that area. If the paper does happen to get torn, just glue it down again with some poly… add another piece of poly dipped paper to repair if, let dry and add a few coats of poly. These floors are so forgivable… you can mess them up and they don’t look messed up…. The imperfections add character to them.

    • I would do mine again… I love them. All I use is polyurethane… it is my glue, my top coats and my sealer… easy peasy

    • I thought my mother was nuts when she papered the floor in our living room with the brown bags from the store, but the end result was fabulous. Paper and poly was all she used and I believe that floor was still intact until the house burned down. I have been thinking about doing my kitchen & pantry.

  18. One more comment… sorry….. I did not use a stain… I just let the polyurethane do it all. My floors looked great without the stain.

  19. Me again… sorry. I used water based polyurethane only.

    • Margie, do you have your floor online somewhere to see? How long has it been? I agree your method sounds best, but would like to see the final color. Do you mix a little at a time of your Poly? Or does the water kind need mixing? Thanks, S:)

    • Margie, did you do any floors over concrete? Would you mind to post which brand of poly and what kind of paper you use? Thanks!

  20. Chelsea R says:

    Thanks so much for the honest update. Many bloggers don’t do that and people go and ruin their houses in the sake of DIY.

  21. Thanks for telling how it did and did not work. I am still going to try it. My upstairs hallway is not hardwood and I do not want to have to buy wood. Saw this in your blog one day and saved it. well we’ll see. Thinking of doing it over the winter.

  22. Marie Carrell says:

    Did you still use the same method to apply the Bona Traffic?

  23. It’s from moisture underneath; that is what causes sealers to blister. It’s actually not an issue with the sealer. Always apply when no chance of humidity but even if you do that, if you have moisture in your slab the sealer traps it. It can also be if you apply sealer too soon after applying the bags as they have moisture in them and there is no where for that moisture to go. Blisters are always caused by trapped gas/moisture below the surface rather than within the sealer.

  24. Do you think this could be done on walls? think this would be awesome in an office.

  25. My floors are incredible. They have no blistering or problems with scratching. I love them. Here are the products I used:
    The beginning floor was asbestos tile. I skim coated with webcrete 95, mixing it with 0ne part weldbond to five parts water.
    I dunked my contractors paper into a bucket of the weldbond mixture (one to five parts water). I scrunched up the paper in the bucket- no need to wrinkle paper first. I let the paper dry over night. I used Bona quick-dri stain and let it dry over night. This stain doe not stay tacky-very nice. Then for next three days after that one coat of bona mega each day. I used the mega “booster” with the last coat on the heavy traffic areas. I used this method throughout my entire house. It has been a year and my floors are still beautiful.

  26. can you do this over a old vintl tile for in my den after removing the carpet

    • You can, but you will want to lightly sand it first so that the the glue adheres properly. Also, when you’re finished you will be able to clearly see the lines in the tile through the paper flooring.

    • Don’t sand if it’s asbestos tile, not safe. Best to do a skim coat as I described above. The lines of the tile won’t show through then.

  27. did the paper bag style on many walls and had over 200 people stop and watch, as we did walls in our gift shop, and ask if we would do their homes. We used brown lunch bags and once wrinkled left over night before using wallpaper paste to apply. In one home I just dry brushed it lightly with gold and people insisted it was real suede

  28. I did the paper flooring technique in my bedroom based off your original post using those products. I felt like I couldn’t get a consistent finish on the poly no matter how many coats I used. Some parts always looked more matte and others more glossy. I also had one corner the pulled up when it all cured. Obviously I didn’t have quite enough glue. But I put a rug in the center and then my bed so no one sees the inperfections but me ;) I LOVED this economical flooring solution and I really appreciate all the hard work and research you have put into this!! Thank you so much!!

  29. Under our carpet is subflooring.. Can I lay it directly onto that? Awesome idea by the way!!

    • Subflooring, like plywood? Yes, you can absolutely paper over wood, it should actually work better than over concrete. Just make sure to fill and sand all the joints in the plywood before papering, or else the seams will show after you are finished.

  30. I am not sure why this bothers me so much that you call this paper bag flooring, but it does. Especially since I saw photos on another site and it was clear you used a roll of brown craft paper and not actual paper bags…at least on one room.

  31. Just wanted you to know that I just got done reading your post on the paper bag floors. I had never seen anything like it and I was intrigued because I’ve worked in the flooring industry for fifteen years and my father for over forty. I just had a discussion with him about the issues you had. He said that something could’ve reacted to it but, more than likely, it’s a moisture issue. If any moisture gets underneath, it would definitely go through the paper material and up to the sealer. This is why you have a problem with the one corner in your boys’ room and the bubbling of the finish in the guest room. Liquids can easily slip between where the base of the wall and the sealer meet. Another issue is most floors aren’t perfectly level and if something is spilled and gets underneath of the paper material, liquid tends to run “downhill” so, basically, if the floors aren’t perfectly level, the liquid will travel, and settle, in the lowest area of the floor (usually a corner) and as it sits…it absorbs into the paper…then between the paper and finish…basically separating the finish and causing it to bubble, crack, chip away, etc. Also, you had questioned whether there is a difference between concrete and wood subfloors, guessing there wasn’t a difference. Actually, there is a huge difference between concrete and wood (sub)floors….HUGE. Concrete tends to hold quite a bit of moisture, at least until it fully cures (it takes 25 years for concrete to cure). When dealing with concrete and wood floors, there are many differences, especially to prepping the floors, in order for any type of flooring(including “traditional” flooring that is typically used) to be installed successfully. I’ve learned that flooring isn’t quite as simple as it seems. I also wanted to mention that moisture isn’t just spilling something on the floor, it also has to do with how much is in your home’s structure, under your home, and also in the air (and the part of the country that you live-humid climates don’t just reak havoc on your hair..lol). I hope this info helps. I never comment on posts but the idea of paper bag floors intrigued me. I know that the issues you’ve faced have to be very frustrating. I also am a mom of very active boys and I love that you are trying to find something that can withstand all of their activity. Sometimes I think it’d be easier to make something bulletproof than boy proof. Good luck.

  32. I’ve never done this work before and your experience is a lesson to learn for me, thanks for your share
    Tonny Tran recently posted..Review Jensen JTA-230 3 Speed Stereo Turntable with Built in SpeakersMy Profile

  33. This is a great tutorial. I will try to make this my my house. Thank for share !

  34. What would I need to do to do this on my back porch?

  35. Georgia Donour says:

    I have had paper bag floors for 18 yrs & they have only lately began to show some wear. I had only a vague idea in my mind so I charged right into the job. After tearing & wrinkling the paper & I used a paint brush & applied ( deluted to paint consistency) wood glue on the printed side with a paint brush & spread out the paper ’til the hall ( 8’x32′) was completely covered. Next I rolled glue on the floor as you would paint & let dry over night. For the next week I brushed satin polyurethane each morning & another before I went to bed. With each coat of poly the finish became smoother. To start this was just a temporary fix but everyone that sees it tells me to not change it! All I have to do to clean it is damp mop & it looks great!

Thank you for your comments!

CommentLuv badge